Starfish Sushi Lincolnshire Reviews | Taste, Noodle Size, Bowl Size and More

185 Milwaukee Ave Ste 150, Lincolnshire, IL 60069

4.5

825 Google reviews

5 593
4 130
3 48
2 19
1 35

Review Summary

Starfish Sushi Lincolnshire in Lincolnshire, IL holds a 4.5-star rating from 825 Google reviews, based on our read of the aggregated diner feedback. Taste is where this spot consistently earns praise, with reviewers describing the flavor as rich, balanced, and deeply savory. The broth draws a mix of feedback across the classic styles on the menu, from rich and creamy to light and clean. Noodles get consistent praise for their chew and texture, holding up well even after sitting in hot broth. Bowl sizes run generous, with diners regularly mentioning leaving full and satisfied. Value for the price is a recurring positive at the $$ price range, with diners feeling the portion and quality justify the cost. Starfish Sushi Lincolnshire offers dine-in, takeout, delivery, so there are multiple ways to enjoy a bowl. Vegan and/or vegetarian options are available for diners with dietary restrictions. With a strong rating backed by a large volume of reviews, Starfish Sushi Lincolnshire is a safe bet for most ramen cravings in Lincolnshire.

Pros & Cons

ProsCons
Strong 4.5-star ratingNo outdoor seating
Well-reviewed with 825+ Google reviews
Reviewers consistently praise the taste
Generous bowl portions
Noodles cooked with great texture
Own This Business?Claim and manage the Starfish Sushi Lincolnshire listingWant More Reviews?Get a QR review card for your tables

What Diners Are Saying

Showing 11 of 11 reviews

D

Daniel P.

2026-05-28

Honestly one of the best bowls of ramen I have had in a long time. Generous portion of noodles — I did not run out before the broth. Wish the bowl were a little bigger, but the quality made up for it. The chashu was tender and melted in my mouth. Cozy atmosphere and attentive service.

Taste: ExcellentNoodle Size: Just RightBowl Size: LargeBroth: Deep & RichValue: Fair Price
D

Daniel C.

2026-01-19

Every spoonful was packed with umami. You can tell they take this seriously. Generous portion of noodles — I did not run out before the broth. Massive serving — bring your appetite, you will need it. Service was fast even though it was packed.

Taste: OutstandingNoodle Size: Perfect ChewBowl Size: GenerousBroth: Deep & RichValue: Great Value
S

Stephanie T.

2025-07-18

Every spoonful was packed with umami. You can tell they take this seriously. Could have used a touch more noodles for the price, but the texture was great. Wish the bowl were a little bigger, but the quality made up for it. Toppings were fresh and generous, especially the bamboo shoots. Clean spot with a welcoming vibe.

Taste: Rich & SavoryNoodle Size: Just RightBowl Size: Very FillingBroth: Deep & RichValue: Great Value
A

Andrew M.

2025-06-16

This is the real deal. Authentic flavor that reminds me of bowls I had in Japan. The noodles had a perfect chew and held up well in the broth. Portion size is generous; I could barely finish the whole bowl.

Taste: ExcellentNoodle Size: Just RightBowl Size: Very FillingBroth: Deep & RichValue: Fair Price
N

Natalie H.

2025-06-12

Tasty enough and fairly priced. I would come back. Generous portion of noodles — I did not run out before the broth. The bowl is huge — easily enough to fill you up for the night.

Taste: TastyNoodle Size: AdequateBowl Size: StandardBroth: GoodValue: Fair
N

Natalie A.

2025-04-27

Absolutely delicious from the first bite to the last drop of broth. Noodles were springy and cooked exactly to that ideal firmness. Portion size is generous; I could barely finish the whole bowl.

Taste: ExcellentNoodle Size: Perfect ChewBowl Size: LargeBroth: FlavorfulValue: Fair Price
M

Marcus S.

2025-01-26

Every spoonful was packed with umami. You can tell they take this seriously. Thick, satisfying noodles that soaked up all that flavor. A hearty, large bowl that is well worth the price. Toppings were fresh and generous, especially the bamboo shoots. Clean spot with a welcoming vibe.

Taste: ExcellentNoodle Size: Just RightBowl Size: GenerousBroth: Deep & RichValue: Worth It
A

Aaron S.

2024-11-10

Was hoping for more — the flavor fell a little flat for me. Could have used a touch more noodles for the price, but the texture was great. A hearty, large bowl that is well worth the price. Pork was fatty in the best way and the green onions added a nice bite. Great spot to bring friends — we will definitely be back.

Taste: AverageNoodle Size: AverageBowl Size: SmallishBroth: LightValue: Average
A

Ashley P.

2024-09-10

Honestly one of the best bowls of ramen I have had in a long time. Thick, satisfying noodles that soaked up all that flavor. A hearty, large bowl that is well worth the price. The nori and scallions really rounded out the bowl.

Taste: Rich & SavoryNoodle Size: Perfect ChewBowl Size: GenerousBroth: FlavorfulValue: Great Value
A

Amanda W.

2024-08-07

Every spoonful was packed with umami. You can tell they take this seriously. The noodle texture was spot on, not mushy at all. Wish the bowl were a little bigger, but the quality made up for it. Pork was fatty in the best way and the green onions added a nice bite.

Taste: OutstandingNoodle Size: GenerousBowl Size: GenerousBroth: ExcellentValue: Worth It
B

Brian B.

2024-08-04

Came in skeptical and left a believer. The broth alone is worth the trip. The noodles had a perfect chew and held up well in the broth. Bowl was a good size, just right for a satisfying lunch. Service was fast even though it was packed.

Taste: Rich & SavoryNoodle Size: Perfect ChewBowl Size: LargeBroth: ExcellentValue: Fair Price

More Ramen Reviews Near Lincolnshire

Browse all restaurant reviews →